Pakistan never had a Lata Mangeshkar show
Join WhatsApp Channel
Join Telegram ChannelRenowned Indian lyricist and poet Javed Akhtar recently made a statement in Lahore, Pakistan, regarding the cultural exchange between India and Pakistan. Akhtar, who was invited to attend the Lahore Literature Festival, spoke about the lack of cultural exchange between the two countries and how Pakistan has never hosted the legendary Indian singer Lata Mangeshkar. In contrast, he pointed out how Indian audiences have always welcomed Pakistani artists such as Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Mehdi Hassan with open arms.
Akhtar’s remarks have sparked a debate on the cultural relations between the two neighboring countries. While some people agree with his views, others feel that his statement is an oversimplification of the complex political and social issues that have plagued the relationship between India and Pakistan.
One of the primary issues that Akhtar touched upon was the lack of cultural exchange between India and Pakistan. He pointed out that despite the fact that Lata Mangeshkar is one of the most celebrated singers in India, she has never performed in Pakistan. Akhtar lamented that the lack of cultural exchange between the two countries is a missed opportunity to promote peace and understanding between the two nations.
However, Akhtar did acknowledge that Indian audiences have always been receptive to Pakistani artists. He specifically mentioned the late Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, a qawwali singer who was widely popular in India, and the late Mehdi Hassan, a ghazal singer who was also well-loved in India. Akhtar highlighted how these artists were welcomed by Indian audiences and how their music transcended national boundaries.
Javed Akhtar jams with Ali Zafa
The issue of cultural exchange between India and Pakistan is a contentious one. While there have been instances of Pakistani artists being welcomed in India, such as the famous concert by Ghulam Ali in Mumbai in 2015, there have also been instances where Pakistani artists have faced opposition and backlash from Indian groups. For example, in 2016, the Indian Motion Picture Producers Association (IMPPA) banned Pakistani artists from working in India following the Uri attacks.
Similarly, there have also been instances where Indian artists have faced opposition in Pakistan. In 2016, the Pakistani cinema owners association banned Indian films from being screened in Pakistan following the Uri attacks. While the ban was eventually lifted, it highlighted the fragile nature of cultural relations between the two countries.
Akhtar’s remarks have once again brought the issue of cultural exchange to the forefront. His call for greater cultural exchange between India and Pakistan is not new, and many people on both sides of the border share his views. However, the political and social realities of the relationship between India and Pakistan make it difficult to achieve meaningful cultural exchange.
Javed Akhtar’s statement in Lahore has once again highlighted the need for greater cultural exchange between India and Pakistan. While his remarks have sparked a debate, it is clear that there is a shared desire among many people in both countries to promote peace and understanding through cultural exchange. However, achieving this goal will require a concerted effort from both governments and societies, as well as a willingness to overcome the political and social obstacles that have prevented greater cultural exchange in the past.
